[Basic Chemicals] Inventories hit a record low, so why is methanol still crashing?
Behind this are two forces pulling against each other: a "tight" supply side and a "weak" demand side. Once you separate these two forces and look at them clearly, this price move stops feeling baffling.
First, the tight supply side. For methanol, domestic production is the bulk, but the coastal market relies heavily on imports, especially cargo from the Middle East. To get Middle Eastern methanol out, the most critical chokepoint is the Strait of Hormuz, and this October's move got stuck right at that strait. In early-to-mid October, passage through the strait was persistently rough, and quite a few Iranian plants simply shut down because they couldn't ship product out and their tanks were full. There's an industry detail worth noting here: the Iranian plants stopped not because equipment broke, but because goods piled up in tanks and couldn't be moved; once tank capacity filled, they were forced to cut output. Logistics got jammed, which in turn choked off production. By mid-to-late October, Iranian plant utilization was only around 37%, producing roughly 13,000 tons a day, a big drop from normal levels. Ships couldn't come through and cargo couldn't reach port, so port inventories naturally drained. In the week of October 8, port inventories were down to just 300,000 tons, 90,000 tons less than the previous week, a record low. To get a sense of how small that is, compare it with output: national methanol production is just over 2 million tons a week, averaging under 300,000 tons a day, meaning that port inventory spread out is only about one day of national output. Once imports shrink, the cargo immediately available along the coast becomes extremely tight, and any little ripple gets amplified.
The domestic production line has actually been ample all along. Domestic methanol mainly comes from three routes: coal-based in the northwest, natural gas-based in the southwest, and coke oven gas-based in north China. This year domestic utilization has been above 80% most of the time, and in late March it even approached 90%. The biggest cost component for domestic production is coal price, and through October thermal coal prices stayed high, giving coal-based methanol a floor. But after methanol prices fell from their highs, upstream margins got noticeably squeezed: on October 19, the profit on Inner Mongolia coal-based methanol was only 319 yuan a ton, versus 941 yuan on October 12, compressed from over nine hundred to just over three hundred, which shows upstream is still making money but the margin has clearly narrowed.
Visibility on the import line isn't high either. In September, Iran loaded roughly 240,000 tons of methanol for China; Galaxy Futures, extrapolating at that pace, estimates October imports at around 700,000 tons, but some market analysis gives a lower range of 300,000 to 400,000 tons. The fact that the two numbers differ so much itself shows how uncertain arrivals are.
But prices didn't keep climbing; instead they fell hard from the highs, and the reason is on the demand side. To understand demand, you first have to see who methanol's downstream buyers are. The olefins made from methanol are the feedstock upstream of plastics, and this route is methanol's biggest source of demand growth; the industry calls it methanol-to-olefins, or MTO. There's a key distinction here: some olefin plants are integrated coal-to-olefins units that produce their own methanol, so whether methanol rises or falls doesn't matter much to them. What's really sensitive are the coastal olefin plants that buy methanol externally; they don't produce any themselves and rely entirely on purchases, so the moment methanol gets expensive they're immediately squeezed. In this October move, it was precisely these external-buying plants that shut down. In early October methanol prices shot up too fast, and the costs of external-buying olefin plants were suddenly pushed up, losing money on every ton they made, with losses at one point widening to 1,800 to 2,000 yuan per ton.
Comments
0